AI May be a Force for Good – But Now We're Headed for a Darker Future.

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is already reconfiguring the world inconspicuous ways. Data powers our global digital economy, and data trends are exposed to AI technologies. Smartphones, smart homes, and intelligent cities affect how we work and communicate, and AI systems are increasingly involved in recruitment decisions, medical diagnosis, and court rulings. It depends on your viewpoint on whether this scenario is utopian or dystopian.

The possible hazards of AI are repeatedly reported. Killer robots and mass unemployment are common concerns, while some people are even afraid of human extinction. More ambitious forecasts suggest that AI will add $15 trillion to the world economy by 2030 and ultimately lead us to some social nirvana.

We need to recognize the effect these developments have on our communities. One critical issue is that AI systems perpetuate current social prejudices – with adverse consequences. Several infamous examples of this phenomenon have gained widespread attention: state-of-the-art automated machine translation systems that generate gender-based outputs, and image recognition systems that identify black people as gorillas.

These problems arise because they use mathematical models (such as neural networks) to identify patterns in large sets of training data. If this data is badly skewed in various ways, its inherent biases will inevitably be learned and reproduced by the trained systems. Racist autonomous technologies are troublesome because they can marginalize groups such as women, ethnic minorities, or the elderly, thus compounding current social imbalances.

For example, if AI systems are trained on police arrest data, any conscious or implicit bias manifested in the current arrest patterns will be replicated by the "predictive police" AI system trained on that data. Recognizing the severe consequences of this, many authoritative organizations have recently recommended that all AI systems should be trained on unbiased data. The Ethical Guidelines released earlier in 2019 by the European Commission made the following recommendation: “When data is collected, it can contain socially constructed prejudices, inaccuracies, and errors. This needs to be discussed before practicing for any data collection.”

Dealing with Biased Data

It all sounds fair enough. Unfortunately, it is sometimes merely challenging to guarantee that such data sets are impartial before training. Thus, a concrete example should clarify this.

All state-of-the-art machine translation systems (such as Google Translate) are trained in pair sentences. The English-French scheme uses data that associates English phrases ("she is tall") with similar French phrases ("Elle est grande"). There may be 500 m of such pairings in a given set of training data, resulting in one billion separate sentences.

All gender-related biases would have to be eliminated from a data set of this nature if we were to prevent the resulting method from generating gender-based outcomes such as the following:
Input: The women started the meeting. They worked efficiently.
Output: Les femmes ont commencé la réunion. Ils ont travaillé efficacement.

The French translation was created using Google Translate on 11 October 2019 and is incorrect: 'Ils' is the male plural subject pronoun in French. It appears here despite the sense that indicates that women are referred to. This is a classic example of a masculine default favored by an automated system due to bias in the training data.

In general, 70% of the gendered pronouns in translation data sets are male, while 30% are female. This is because the texts used for this reason tend to refer more to men than to women. In order to prevent translation systems from replicating these existing biases, specific phrase pairs would have to be removed from the data, so that both male and female pronouns were 50 per cent/50 percent on both the English and French sides. This would prevent the system from assigning higher probabilities to male pronouns.

Nouns and adjectives will also need to be balanced by 50 per cent/50 percent, of course, as they can imply gender in both languages ('actor,' 'actress,' 'new,' 'new') so on. However, this drastic down-sampling would inevitably drastically reduce the training data available, thereby reducing the quality of the translations generated.

And even if the resulting data subset were completely gender-balanced, it would still be distorted in all kinds of other ways ( e.g., race or age). It would be difficult to eliminate all these prejudices. If one person just spent five seconds reading every one billion sentences in the training results, it would take 159 years to review all of them – and that implies a willingness to work all day and night, without lunch breaks.

An Alternative?

Therefore, it is impractical to expect all training data sets to be unbiased before AI systems are designed. Such high-level requirements usually assume that "AI" is a homogeneous cluster of mathematical models and algorithmic approaches

Different AI tasks involve different types of systems. And the full extent of this diversity hides the real problems presented by (say) highly distorted training results. This is regrettable since it means that other solutions to the issue of data bias are ignored.

For example, a trained machine translation system's biases can be greatly reduced if the system is adapted after being trained on a broader, ultimately biased data set. This can be done using a much smaller, less skewed data set. Hence, most of the data may be strongly biased, but there is no need for a system trained on it. Unfortunately, these strategies are seldom explored by those responsible for establishing recommendations and regulatory mechanisms for AI research.

If AI programs merely exacerbate current social imbalances, they impede rather than promote meaningful social change. If the AI systems that we increasingly use daily were much less biased than we are, they could help us identify and confront our own lurking biases.

This is definitely what we should be working for. And so AI developers need to think much more carefully about the social implications of the systems they create. In contrast, those who write about AI need to understand in more depth how AI systems are actually planned and developed. Thus, if we ever approach either a technical idyll or a catastrophe, the former would be preferable.

115 comments

  1. Prdjkx

    Uwgcul - impotence definition Vblhlr

  2. Ugtfqk

    how to cure erectile dysfunction at home - best ed pill for diabetics ed meds

  3. Gdhqjz

    isotretinoin 5mg - 70 mg accutane accutane.com

  4. Fywnbg

    buy amoxil online - buy amoxicillin 500 mg mexico amoxicillin brand over the counter

  5. Uknxva

    vardenafil shop online - buy vardenafil online vardenafil levitra

  6. Viwmbb

    stromectol pills - stromectol stromectol coronavirus

  7. Wqlmrl

    tadalafil 20mg mexico - cialis pill price in india cialis medicine

  8. Lrglzg

    stromectol 15 mg - ivermectin 2

  9. junimeridio

    surprised hydroxychloroquine and cardiovascular risk increased [url=https://hydroxychloroquined.online/ ]does canada use hydroxychloroquine[/url] polysomnography hydroxychloroquine drug interaction

  10. Vuxrfo

    where can you get accutane online no rx - buy accutane online canada buy accutane from india

  11. Aqjvpt

    lyrica 150 mg buy online - site real canadian pharmacy

  12. Ojqwpp

    kroger amoxicillin price - amoxicillin 500mg capsules for sale can you buy amoxicillin over the counter

  13. Mxpgdr

    viagra online canada generic - generic sildenafil prescription generic viagra soft tabs online

  14. Qixtmt

    order pharmacy online egypt - where can i buy cialis in singapore cialis tablets 20mg price in india

  15. Kxfaso

    ivermectin over counter - ivermectin 0.08 oral solution generic stromectol for humans

  16. Kfwxzq

    how to get prednisone prescription - order prednisone 10mg over the counter prednisone medicine

  17. Obosvj

    modafinil anxiety - provigil a narcotic modafinil buy

  18. Williamsmesk

    online dating service
    [url="http://datingsitesfirst.com/?"]dating sites for teens[/url]

  19. Williamsmesk

    dating website
    [url="http://datingonlinecome.com/?"]ryan paevey dating[/url]

  20. Ieuyhn

    what is azithromycin used to treat - low cost zithromax azithromycine

  21. Ixfqec

    where can i buy furosemide without a script - furosemide 40 mg lasix uses

  22. Brkcra

    clomiphene generic - clomiphene tablets clomid canada

  23. Ctvpfs

    cheap viagra canada - cost of viagra pills in india 25 mg viagra cost

  24. Ytzzaa

    20mg tadalafil - perscription drugs from canada how much does cialis cost

  25. Tjvbzv

    cost of ivermectin pill - stromectol 15 mg ivermectina 6 mg

  26. KevinLig

    francois xxxx gay dating
    gay dating web site
    [url="http://gaychatus.com?"]singapore gay dating website[/url]

  27. KevinLig

    dating 90 year gay old men
    pocatello gay dating
    [url="http://gaydatingzz.com?"]gay dating sim game grumps[/url]

  28. Htdmwh

    real online casino - gambling casino online win real money online casino for free

  29. Dwlsru

    best ed pills on amazon - cheapest ed pills ed miracle pill

  30. KevinLig

    gay guy dating the devil
    gay dating sites]
    [url="http://gaychatus.com?"]list of gay dating websites[/url]

  31. Cqvwzm

    prednisone 5 mg - prednisone prescription online prednisone prescription

  32. KevinLig

    4chan gay dating
    gay chub/chaser dating
    [url="http://gaydatingzz.com?"]dating gay services[/url]

  33. Dtpdci

    viagra – uk - viagra cream buy online how to buy viagra in canada

  34. KevinLig

    gay dating meetup in nyc
    gay guy dating trans man
    [url="http://gaychatrooms.org?"]gay males dating site[/url]

  35. Rlsbpu

    cialis paypal australia - Brand cialis for sale where to purchase cialis online

  36. KevinLig

    gay dating page
    gay daddies dating
    [url="http://gaychatus.com?"]gay man dating woman[/url]

  37. ivermectin dosage chart

    Greate post. Keep posting such kind of information on your blog.
    Im really impressed by it.
    Hello there, You've performed an incredible job. I'll certainly digg it
    and individually suggest to my friends. I'm sure they will
    be benefited from this web site. http://herreramedical.org/ivermectin

  38. Ojcpxa

    stromectol oral - buy ivermectin online ivermectin australia

  39. azithromycin suspension refrigerate

    Hey There. I discovered your blog using msn. That is an extremely neatly written article.

    I'll make sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your helpful information. Thank you for the post.
    I will definitely comeback. https://buszcentrum.com/zithromax.htm

  40. KevinLig

    gay bears dating
    gay senior dating site
    [url="http://gaydatingzz.com?"]dating site for older gay men[/url]

  41. Xyarlf

    otc ed pills that work - medications list otc ed pills that work

  42. Jkxwnm

    ventolin price usa - onventolinp ventolin medication

  43. Xztrtz

    where can i buy cytotec over the counter in usa - cytotec purchase buy cytotec 200 mg online

  44. Aplgpn

    2985 doxycycline - doxycycline 100 mg buy online doxycycline canada brand name

  45. Pbaqil

    neurontin 1000 mg - levothyroxine rx discount levothyroxine generic 112 mcg

  46. Viagra

    Acheter Du Cialis En Toute Legalite

  47. Tlqknx

    sildenafil 50mg otc - viagra 100mg tablet price in india

  48. Noel

    Thanks for finally talking about > AI May be a Force
    for Good – But Now We're Headed for a Darker Future. < Liked it!

    Also visit my web blog what web hosting

  49. Titismles

    http://buystromectolon.com/ - where can i buy stromectol in the usa

  50. hydroxychloroquine dose for coronavirus

    Howdy! Quick question that's entirely off topic. Do you know how to make your
    site mobile friendly? My blog looks weird when browsing from my iphone.

    I'm trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to correct this problem.
    If you have any suggestions, please share. Cheers! http://hydroxychloroquined.online/

  51. poidayrap
  52. Malissa

    Have you ever considered about including a little bit
    more than just your articles? I mean, what you say is fundamental and everything.
    Nevertheless think of if you added some great photos or video
    clips to give your posts more, "pop"! Your content is excellent but with images and clips, this
    site could certainly be one of the best in its field. Amazing blog!

    Feel free to visit my blog post ... are quest bars (t.co)

  53. Oscineded
  54. Zquvvj

    vardenafil cena - buy generic vardenafil uk buy generic vardenafil from india online

  55. Oscar

    I do not know whether it's just me or if everybody else encountering problems with your blog.
    It looks like some of the written text in your posts are running off the screen. Can somebody else
    please provide feedback and let me know if this is happening to
    them too? This could be a problem with my browser because I've had this happen previously.
    Cheers

    Also visit my webpage quest bars when - t.co,

  56. Viryan

    ivermectin medicine - ivermectin 3mg dosage

  57. Maroweawl
  58. NoffAnend
  59. Alfredo

    After looking into a number of the articles on your website, I honestly
    appreciate your technique of blogging. I added it to my bookmark
    site list and will be checking back in the near future. Please check out my website as well and tell me
    how you feel.

    Take a look at my web-site :: scoliosis surgery when

  60. Ben

    Great article.

    my page in asmr (j.mp)

  61. Jxmkpn

    buy prednisone online no prescription - cost of prednisone deltasone 5mg cost

  62. Kacey

    The other day, while I was at work, my cousin stole my apple ipad and tested to see if it can survive asmr a (bit.ly) thirty foot drop,
    just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad is now broken and she
    has 83 views. I know this is totally off topic but I had
    to share it with someone!

  63. PatrickSix

    speed dating for gay men
    gay dating a narcissist reddit
    [url="http://freegaychatnew.com?"]signs if dating a gay guy[/url]

  64. Rlcraz

    isotretinoin 10 mg - accutane cream india accutane medication cost

  65. PatrickSix

    best gay dating service
    free gay dating site online
    [url="http://freegaychatnew.com?"]gay dating service pittsburgh[/url]

  66. Tia

    Generally I do not read post on blogs, however I
    wish to say that this write-up very compelled me to check out
    and do so! Your writing style has been surprised me.
    Thanks, quite nice post.

    Feel free to visit my site: off asmr (http://bitly.com/)

  67. Arftsx

    buy amoxicillin - amoxicillin 250 mg buy amoxicilin 500

  68. Dewitt

    I go to see each day some blogs and sites to read articles asmr or (http://j.mp/2WShZQd) reviews, but this webpage offers feature based posts.

  69. itewhex

    https://buypropeciaon.com/ - finasteride receding hairline

  70. PatrickSix

    gay dating thunder bay
    gay dating ct
    [url="http://freegaychatnew.com?"]closeted gay dating site[/url]

  71. Ozmzyy

    medrol 4mg price - methylprednisolone otc lyrica tablet price

  72. traitly
  73. Felicitas

    Hmm is anyone else experiencing problems with scoliosis surgery
    the images on this blog loading? I'm trying to determine if its a
    problem on my end or if it's the blog. Any responses would be greatly appreciated.

  74. Hcphjb

    academic writers online - essay help service money can t buy everything essay

  75. hydroxychloroquine and coronavirus

    I've read a few good stuff here. Definitely price bookmarking for revisiting.
    I wonder how a lot effort you place to create the sort of great
    informative web site. https://hhydroxychloroquine.com/

  76. Michaelnix

    gay friendly dating sites
    completely free gay dating
    [url="dating-gaym.com?"]gay and lesbian dating sites[/url]

  77. Henrybrura

    is ayi a big gay dating site
    gay dating scene nashville
    [url="http://gayedating.com?"]chennsi gay dating[/url]

  78. sefeanaps
  79. cialis 5mg best price

    cialis natural replacement

  80. Wnfzay

    buy tadalafil 100mg - Cialis online us price cialis 20 mg

  81. prescription women sildenafil

    If some one wants expert view regarding running a blog
    afterward i advise him/her to pay a visit this blog, Keep up the good job. http://www.deinformedvoters.org/viagra-generic

  82. Stromectol

    Productos Kamagra

  83. Xvgqcs

    fda ivermectin - stromectol price uk buy stromectol 3mg

  84. Henrybrura

    gay chubby dating sites
    best gay catholic dating site
    [url="http://gayedating.com/?"]free gay dating - seniors[/url]

  85. Yttete

    prednisone 4 tablets daily - prednisone buy nz prednisone brand

  86. Henrybrura

    free gay dating sites in canada
    gay sugar daddies dating
    [url="http://gay-singles-dating.com/?"]gay dating greece[/url]

  87. Xpxerp

    lasix online canada - buy clomiphene can you buy furosemide online

  88. Lasix

    Cialis Madrid Entrega En Mano

  89. Henrybrura

    free gay men dating
    bear gay dating
    [url="http://gay-singles-dating.com/?"]gay dating simulation games[/url]

  90. Pqekdd

    ventolin australia price - ventolin price uk cost of ventolin in usa

  91. Baimame
  92. cialis generic vs tadalafil reviews

    I just like the helpful information you provide in your articles.
    I will bookmark your weblog and check again here frequently.

    I am rather sure I'll be told many new stuff proper here!
    Best of luck for the next! https://tadalafili.com/

  93. Henrybrura

    gay herpes dating
    gay chicago dating sites
    [url="http://gay-singles-dating.com/?"]thats gay we've been dating[/url]

  94. twilsOm
  95. Hhcubk

    cytotec tablet online - cytotec tablet price cytotec buy online india

  96. Viola
  97. FrauffLup
  98. CoahPhoda

    https://buyplaquenilcv.com/ - plaquenil dosage for lupus

  99. suepext

    http://buylasixshop.com/ - furosemide over the counter substitute

  100. Cxzseh

    stromectol pills canada - ivermectin 3 mg stromectol buy

  101. Axiotolal

    https://buyzithromaxinf.com/ - valtrex for sale in the uk

  102. Cputza

    stromectol generic name - ivermectin medication buy ivermectin cream for humans

  103. generic price for tadalafil

    hi!,I really like your writing very a lot! proportion we be in contact extra approximately your article on AOL?
    I require a specialist in this house to resolve my problem.

    Maybe that's you! Having a look forward to look you. http://herreramedical.org/tadalafil

  104. addibly
  105. Lsvcqc

    tadalafil generic name - tadalapills.com tadalafil 10 mg

  106. buy hydroxychloroquine 200 mg

    Priligy Cos'E

  107. icolladia
  108. ciprofloxacin and flagyl

    We're a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme
    in our community. Your web site offered us with
    valuable info to work on. You've done an impressive job and our whole community will be grateful to you. http://antiibioticsland.com/Flagyl_ER.htm

  109. priligy

    Canadian Viagra Pharmacy

  110. Jbqxqr

    accutane 1mg - buy accutane cream 120 mg accutane daily

  111. Foster

    Глубинные системные расстановки.
    Системные перестановки Новые семейные расстановки.
    Расстановки. Системные-расстановки.
    Новые семейные расстановки.

    Растановки.

  112. promethazine in canada

    Wirkung Viagra Bei Frau

  113. Efzmwg

    help with term paper - help writing research paper academia writing

  114. Gtldwv

    ivermectin 2 - ivermectin canada ivermectin for humans walmart

  115. Milla

    socialblade, lieferando gutschein американская история ужасов 5 akinator, twich

Comment

Your email address will not be disclosed. The required fields are marked with*.

Related recommendation

No related articles!

微信扫一扫,分享到朋友圈

AI May be a Force for Good –  But Now We're Headed for a Darker Future.